By Helen Sim
Huw Morgan, who curates this blog, confesses to having eaten crickets and spiders. In Vietnam. Deep-fried. And how were they? “Crunchy.”
Eating insects is something many cultures do. In Australia, bogong moths, honey ants and witchetty grubs have been on the menu. For those who have not yet indulged, consider: insects may in future come to a plate near you.
In the Wall Street Journal last year two Dutch entomologists pointed out the advantages of eating insects. They’re “high in protein, B vitamins and minerals like iron and zinc”, “easier to raise than livestock” and “produce less waste”. (To which one might add, they might be more acceptable to some vegetarians and animal rights activists.It’s hard to imagine a scandal over slaughterhouse practices if the animals being dispatched are mealworms.)
Outraged readers posted their displeasure: “You couldn’t pay me to substitute insects for meat … I’d start raising my own cattle and chickens before that EVER happened.” Someone who’d sampled a few kinds of critters was not impressed: “Sand worms are OK, but they scream for ketchup.”
But eating insects does have advantages – and in a small, densely populated country such as the Netherlands, they must loom large.
Some of those advantages would be shared by cultured muscle tissue – artificial meat – and indeed attempts are being made overseas to develop such a product. Perhaps artificial meat will come into production, and gain acceptability, before “table insects” do.
American food writer Michael Pollan, quoting the anthropologist Claude Levi-Strauss, points out that food must not only be “good to eat” but also “good to think”. Would you eat insects? Would I? I’ve never eaten insects myself: among the molluscs, I’ve happily eaten oysters but drawn the line at snails, even ones raised for the table. We’ve worked hard to keep insect pests at bay, both in the field and on the shelf; worked hard to keep the weevils out of the flour and off our plates. Could we ever turn this loathing around?
The boundaries of acceptability will be shaped by circumstance. World population is increasing by 77 million a year. About 43 per cent of Earth’s land is already given over to cities or agricultural landscapes. If we don’t become more efficient in food production, this amount is set to grow – with possibly dire effects on the whole biosphere, biologists worry. Given this, eating insects may come to look increasingly sensible. Pass the crickets, please.
 Marcel Dicke and Arnold Van Huis. “The Six-Legged Meat of the Future.” The Wall Street Journal, 19 February 2011. http://tiny.cc/jgz2fw
 “Hamburger Junction”. The Economist, 25 February 2012. http://www.economist.com/node/21548147
 Anthony D. Barnovsky and 21 co-authors. “Approaching a state shift in the Earth’s biosphere”. Nature 486, pp. 52–5 (07 June 2012) doi:10.1038/nature11018
22nd March 2013 at 2:45 pm
I love the thought of the little critters appearing on our plates, disguised by indulgent or humorous menu listings, as long as they taste good.
18th June 2012 at 3:23 pm
I await the publication of the CSIRO Total Wellbeing Insect Diet. From my experience the grilled silkworm didn’t even reach the bottom of the throat it was that disgusting. The scorpion was okay I guess. I have a far better solution that will solve the needs of both carnivores and the environment. Cannibalism! I’ll look forward to that Total Wellbeing book too.
22nd March 2013 at 2:47 pm
Andrew Wright true and scary. Images of the walking dead
6th January 2017 at 2:39 pm
Yes, yes, and yes.